Friday, June 6, 2008

But where do the "churched" go?

So there is a lot of talk, sadly in Lutheran circles, about this whole "churched" vs "unchurched" issue; that is to say, trying to get the "unchurched" into "church" (or something that claims the title "church", anyway). In my surfing of the blogosphere, I came across this article, http://www.ideateblog.com/2008/05/choosing-who-to-offend.html. Well, I'm offended. But that's another topic for another time.

The question I want to address right now is "where do the 'churched' go?"
Obviously, this guy wants to pack his audience with the "unchurched," presumably so that they may undergo "churching" and thus become "churched." So first of all, lets address this process of "churching." My hope is that this is analagous to making disciples by baptizing and teaching, though I fear it is probably more along the lines of entertaining and empowering (or insert your own trendy church-growth buzzword here). But for the sake of argument, lets assume the first option, that the process of "churching" is really making disciples by baptizing and teaching. What then? Since their whole outlook is tailored completely to "churching" the "unchurched" what is there for the newly "churched"? Nothing? The sheep must be starving.

There is a reason that we emphasize "the Gospel purely preached and the Sacraments rightly administered": because this is how Christ's sheep are fed. The terrible reality of this mentality of "reaching the unchurched" is that the church itsself ceases to be a church and becomes something else entirely. A bit of searching will not lead you to the impression that this guy's church (Jefferson Hills) is Lutheran, much less LCMS (though, apparently, we send them lots of Ablaze! money for things like signs written by Satan http://www.satanhates.com/).

So where do these newly "churched" go? I have no idea where they're going now, but I hope they find their way to a Lutheran church that isn't ashamed of its heritage and will faithfully feed them God's word through the pure Gospel and Sacraments; where they will become disciples through baptism and teaching, making these "churches" for the "unchurched" completely unnecessary at best, and detrimental at worst (what's worse than bringing someone to life only to let them starve to death? Sounds like torture to me).

An excellent treatment on the subject of "churched" vs "unchurched" can be found here: http://www.redeemerlosalamos.org/pages/unchurched.html

No comments: