Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Curvatus in se, perhaps?

Among my family this past Father's Day, we had a discussion about one of my uncles who is studying to become some sort of reformed pastor. This got me thinking about the differences between Arminian, Calvinist, and Lutheran doctrines of salvation and free-will/predestination.

So, what's the big deal, anyway? Why spend time pointing out (and ultimately condemning) these differences?

Calvinism
The Calvinist groups among us teach what is termed "double predestination," that is to say, that the "elect" were chosen by God to be saved, while everyone else was created for eternal damnation. Needless to say, this paints a fairly vicious picture of God, creating people to be condemned? So, how does a good Calvinist know that he is among the elect? Unfortunately, it is to look at their own lives, even if as simple as things like going to church and such, they are looking at laws they have obeyed to see if they are among the elect. In this way, it becomes a Theology of Glory of sorts, as it becomes more and more reliant on visible evidence in the life of the person. Ultimately, this works-righteousness destroys grace and turns the sinner inward upon himself, rather than outward to others: curvatus in se (curved in on onesself).

Arminianism
Our Arminian friends, most visible of which are the Baptists, spend their time pretending that humans can exercise free will in matters relating to eternal salvation. As if a dead person can do things! Regardless, they too look inward upon themselves for their salvation, the decision, they so self-righteously point to, that they made to follow Christ. Of couse, this sets up the self as the ultimate savior (works-righteousness again) and destroys grace. Their faith lives and dies by this decision they made: unfortunately, as I have noted before, this is at its essence, trying to justify onesself by works of the law, and is ultimately doomed to failure. A very dangerous theology of glory, to be sure, and as with double predestination, points the sinner to himself (curvatus in se, again).

So what's the big deal? Well, in a word, everything. These theologies of glory destroy justification by grace through faith in Jesus Christ alone. As Paul declares in Romans 3:28, "For we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law" (ESV).

As Lutherans, we know that certainly, God, in his divine mercy, chose from out of the world his people that he saves (Rom 8:30); but we also know that he desires to save all (1 Tim 2:4) and so could not have chosen some to be condemned. As Lutherans, we look to God and his revelation to us in Christ crucified for our salvation. To know we are saved, we point to our Baptism, to Christ's true body and blood in the Sacrament, and most importantly, to Christ's atoning death on the cross to know that we are saved. Thanks be to God that "in these last days he has spoken to us by his Son" (Heb 1:2a).

No comments: